New Energy Solutions
Comparing Home Water Heating Technology – Solar Hot Water vs Heat Pumps
Two renewable energy technologies for home water heating are popular for residential use: solar hot water and heat pumps. Both options are efficient and sustainable but operate differently and offer unique advantages. Understanding the differences between the two systems will help us choose the best system for your heating needs.
Let's explore each technology, how it works, its benefits, and considerations for selecting the right system. We will also discuss recommendations and tips for more savings and eco-friendly water heating solutions.
Key Takeaways:
Different Technologies, Similar Goals: Solar hot water and heat pumps provide energy-efficient water heating solutions, but their methods differ. Solar hot water systems rely on direct sunlight, while heat pumps extract heat from the air, even in cooler conditions.
Advantages of Heat Pumps: Heat pumps are more versatile and reliable year-round. Combined with solar, heat pumps not only reduce energy costs for water heating but also support other household energy needs.
Limitations of Solar Hot Water: While solar hot water systems are eco-friendly and use free solar energy, they are weather-dependent and cater only to water heating. This limits their overall contribution to household energy efficiency compared to solar-powered heat pumps.
A Long-Term, Comprehensive Solution: Investing in a solar panel system with a heat pump offers greater financial and environmental benefits. The declining costs of solar panels make this combination more practical, providing a holistic approach to reducing energy costs and enhancing sustainability.
The Key Differences of Solar Hot Water vs Heat Pumps
Both solar hot water systems and heat pumps offer energy-efficient solutions for heating water, but their approach and capabilities differ significantly.
Solar Hot Water Systems
A solar hot water system captures sunlight through solar collectors installed on your roof. The system heats the water in a storage tank and prepares it for use. Solar hot water works effectively on sunny days but relies heavily on direct sunlight to operate efficiently. On cloudy or overcast days, its performance can drop. You may need to rely on backup energy sources to heat your water.
Heat Pumps
On the other hand, a heat pump extracts heat from the air even in colder conditions and uses that energy to heat your water. It works somewhat like a reverse fridge—drawing in heat and transferring it to the water inside the tank. Heat pumps are incredibly efficient, using less energy than traditional electric water heaters.
The best part is that solar energy can power heat pumps. The combination enables your heat pump to run on clean, renewable energy. It also further reduces your reliance on the grid and lowers energy costs.
Benefits and Drawbacks of Solar Hot Water vs. Heat Pumps
We've now explored how these systems work. Let's proceed with breaking down their advantages and disadvantages.
Solar hot water systems are a popular choice among eco-conscious homeowners because they use free energy from the sun to heat water. Installing one can lead to significant savings on energy bills over time. Additionally, in certain areas, you can qualify for government incentives and rebates that can help reduce installation costs. However, this system does come with a few limitations.
Since solar hot water depends on sunlight, its efficiency can drop on cloudy days or during the winter months. You might need to rely on backup energy to heat your water. Another drawback is that solar hot water systems only support your home's water heating. They don’t help reduce energy use for other household needs.
On the flip side, heat pumps provide an energy-efficient way to heat water by drawing heat from the air, even on cooler days. They use significantly less energy than traditional electric water heaters.
Heat pumps can work year-round, which makes them more reliable than solar hot water systems. Perhaps their noteworthy advantage is their versatility. A heat pump with your solar installed at home can provide a more comprehensive energy solution.
However, heat pumps require some electricity to operate, though integrating them with solar panels helps offset this. The upfront cost of installing a heat pump system is usually higher than that of traditional water heaters. However, the long-term savings often make it a valuable investment.
Solar-Powered Heat Pump is a Smarter Choice
A solar heat pump presents a compelling case when considering the most efficient and cost-effective solution for heating water. Solar provides a steady source of renewable energy. It supports your water heating needs and other loads at home. You are not only reducing your energy costs for heating water but also cutting down on electricity usage for appliances like lights, washing machines, and air conditioning.
Heat pumps can work efficiently even in less-than-ideal weather, and solar panels can generate energy year-round. The real advantage of combining solar panels with a heat pump is long-term efficiency and sustainability. A heat pump powered by solar allows you to take full advantage of your home’s renewable energy potential. The beauty of this setup is it aligns with both financial savings and environmental goals.
Why Solar Hot Water Can Be Less Desirable in the Future
The limitations of solar hot water are becoming more apparent, especially as the cost of solar panels continues to drop. Let's say you will install a solar hot water system that costs $5000. Your water heating system uses free energy from the sun, but what about the rest of your household appliances?
In comparison, for just a little more (around $7000, you can install a standard 6kW solar panel system that powers your heat pump and supports other appliances in your home.
The problem with a solar hot water system is that it addresses just one aspect of your energy needs—hot water. It’s great if you’re focused solely on that, but it doesn’t offer the broader utility that comes with a solar system.
Rather than relying on an additional energy source to power your hot water system, solar panels can provide enough energy to power your heat pump and your household’s everyday needs. All while lowering your long-term energy bills.
Think Long Term
Solar hot water and heat pumps are long-term investments, so thinking long-term can go a long way. The initial cost of both systems can be high, but they offer exceptional value in the long run.
If you are ready to explore these options with a solar expert, our team is here to help. Contact us today for expert advice and a personalised consultation. A professional installation can get you started on the path to greater savings and sustainability.
FAQ
Frequently Asked Questions about Installing Solar Power
There are great government rebates/incentives still in place for eligible households. Basically, the larger the panel array, the more STCs your solar system generates as it is based on the expected output of the system over time.
When you buy a solar system, the purchase price is normally reduced by the value of the STCs created by your system. You simply fill out a form on the day of installation to confirm that the system has been installed, and that’s it. There is no additional paperwork that you need to do.
Small-scale Technology Certificates (STCs)
Small-scale Technology Certificates (STC’s) – previously known as Renewable Energy Certificates or RECS – are created when a Renewable Energy System such as a Solar PV system is installed.
The number of STC’s depends on the predicted amount of energy generated and hence the larger the system the greater the rebate. In essence, one STC is created for every megawatt-hour of production capacity of the system.
This is further multiplied by the number of years the system is likely to generate energy (for home solar systems, this is usually 15 years, although the life of the solar panels themselves is considerably more than that).
This incentive program is being phased out until 2030, so each year the number of certificates your system is eligible for reduces.
STC Price
The system for trading and pricing STCs for small systems is managed by the Small-scale Renewable Energy Scheme (SRES).
STCs are bought by Liable Parties (usually electricity retailers) and must be surrendered at the end of each quarter. As the number of STCs that are required to be surrendered is a fixed amount each year, but the number of STCs created is variable, the price paid for STCs also varies and is determined by supply and demand.
The Federal Government legislated in 2010 a fixed price for STCs by implementing a Clearing House system where STCs can be bought and sold for $40. However, there is no requirement for Liable Parties to purchase from the Clearing House, so they are likely to only do so if there is a shortage of STCs or the market price exceeds $40. There is currently a surplus of STCs in the market which means the market price of STC’s below $40
The Feed In Tariff is only something you need to worry about if you don’t have battery storage.
The price your chosen energy retailer pays for any excess electricity generated from your solar panels is recorded as a credit on your power bill.
In NSW, solar power is fed into your home as it is generated and your household will use it first before you draw power from the grid.
This means that for every kWh of solar power used in the home you are directly saving money you’d spend on your power bill. This reduction in your power bill is the main financial benefit of solar power.
Everything else will be bought up at an agreed rate by your electricity retailer.
At the moment, most feed-in tariffs are between 5 and 10 cents per kWh, with many being about 7 cents. They bounce up and down a lot, for example in previous years they have been up over 20 cents per kWh. Typically, they are always at least 5 cents per kWh.
Once you sign up for a 1KOMMA5° Installation, we immediately submit your grid application to the relevant energy distributor. For systems up to 5kWs, this is a formality. For larger systems it can take a few days or more. Once we receive approval, your installation will be managed by our installation coordinator, who will welcome you to 1KOMMA5° and book an installation date for you. This is generally booked within around two weeks and installation dates are available Monday to Friday, weather permitting.
We endeavour to have your system installed within 2-4 weeks unless you request us to hold for whatever reason. Due to our strict safety policy, we do not install solar systems when it rains. In the event of inclement weather, we will rebook your installation as soon as possible. We always work with your requests as we strongly recommend that someone be home on the day of installation.
Green Loans can be an affordable way to pay for your solar power system and is only available for approved products. As a Clean Energy Council Accredited installer, all our systems qualify.
Green Loans can be used to finance 1KOMMA5° systems from $1,000 to $30,000 over a 2-7 year term. Once you have received a referral from 1KOMMA5°, online approval usually occurs within 1-2 business days. Green Loans have a competitive fixed interest rate that is as low as 7.99% p.a.* | Comparison rate 9.21% p.a.^ Establishment fee of $299 added to the loan amount. $2.70 per week account keeping fee included in repayments.
To be eligible to apply you must:
Be over 18 years old and an Australian resident or citizen
Own or be purchasing a home
Be employed, self-employed, a self-funded retiree; or is receiving the Government Age Pension
Have an Australian driver’s license or Passport
Provide two most recent payslips or 90 days of bank statements
There are a number of good, competitive Green Loan providers – ask us about the options available.
More Helpful Articles:
1KOMMA5° Blog
Need more information?
Head over to the 1KOMMA5° blog for more helpful tips and other important guides on everything solar, from inverters, panels and batteries to how to make the most of your investment for years to come.